Boston Fed President Susan Collins says a December rate cut isn’t a ‘done deal’
By Nick Timiraos
Updated Nov. 15, 2024 5:13 pm ET
Boston Fed President Susan Collins. Photo: Andrew Harrer/Bloomberg News
Stocks fell Friday, following a solid retail-sales report that could bolster the case that the economy is strong and may not need support in the form of lower borrowing costs.
Separately, a Federal Reserve official said it was too soon to say whether the central bank should cut interest rates at its meeting next month.
Another rate cut in December is “certainly on the table, but it’s not a done deal,” said Boston Fed President Susan Collins in an interview late Thursday. “There’s more data that we will see between now and December, and we’ll have to continue to weigh what makes sense.”
All three major U.S. stock indexes finished the day in the red. The Nasdaq Composite fell for a fourth consecutive day and was down more than 3% for the week. The S&P 500 lost more than 2% on the week, and the Dow Jones Industrial Average lost more than 1%.
The week marked a sharp reversal from the red-hot performance at the start of the month. In the previous week, stocks rose to new highs after Donald Trump won the presidential election and the Federal Reserve cut rates by a quarter point.
The latest moves highlighted investor uncertainty about whether the Fed is in a position to continue cutting rates as much as markets have come to expect—in part because the economy continues to hold up well.
On Friday, the Commerce Department said that retail sales gained 0.4% in October from September, better than economists’ forecasts for a 0.3% increase. Officials also revised their figures for September sales growth sharply upward to 0.8%, from an initial estimate of 0.4% growth.
“Various speeches by Fed officials show growing concern that disinflation is hitting a wall,” Jefferies analyst Thomas Simons wrote to clients after the data Friday. “But we do not think there will be enough evidence to confirm these hypotheses before the next meeting.”
The Fed’s next meeting is Dec. 17-18. Officials will see data on inflation and employment for November before that meeting.
Collins said Thursday she didn’t see any evidence that inflation was picking up due to new sources of strength in the economy, aligning herself with a view Fed Chair Jerome Powell expressed last week. Both of them suggested recent inflation stickiness has instead been an echo or “catch-up” effect of large price increases from the past few years, such as car insurance costs rising to reflect past increases in car prices that have since subsided.
“As far as I can tell, I do not see evidence of new price pressures,” said Collins. Firmer inflation in recent months instead reflects “the effects of the longer-term dynamics of past shocks,” she said.
The Fed cut interest rates at its two most recent meetings, beginning with a half-percentage-point reduction in September amid signs the labor market might be weakening. Officials lowered their benchmark rate by a quarter point, to a range between 4.5% and 4.75%, at their meeting last week.
Collins, who will take a turn next year as a voting member of the Fed’s rate-setting committee, said she supported both of those cuts. “We will get to a place where it will be appropriate to feel our way more slowly and more cautiously,” said Collins.
Expectations in futures markets for a December rate cut have bounced around in recent days. They jumped to around 80% on Wednesday, from 60%, after the October consumer-price index wasn’t as bad as feared. But then they fell back to 60% after Powell said Thursday that “stout” economic performance recently would allow the Fed to proceed carefully with rate cuts.
Collins said she thought it would be appropriate to continue lowering interest rates to a so-called neutral stance that neither spurs nor slows economic activity after more than a year in which the Fed held interest rates at a restrictive setting. Collins said she thinks policy is still restrictive.
“I don’t see an argument for maintaining restrictive policy when there is not evidence of new price pressures, and the old dynamics are perhaps unevenly and gradually resolving over time,” she said.
Jack Pitcher and Paul Kiernan contributed to this article.
Write to Nick Timiraos at Nick.Timiraos@wsj.com
Advertisement
Inflation and the Economy
Analysis from The Wall Street Journal, selected by the editors
Inflation Has Cooled, but Americans Are Still Seething Over Prices
Lower Interest Rates Don’t Guarantee a Soft Landing
The American Dream Feels Out of Reach for Most
Inflation’s Impact on the Poor vs. the Rich
Copyright ©2024 Dow Jones & Company, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
Appeared in the November 16, 2024, print edition as ‘Rate-Cut Doubts Nettle Nervous Investors’.
Show Conversation (447)
What to Read Next
Heard on the Street
Trump Crypto Craze Sent Bitcoin Miners Surging, but Watch Out
November 16, 2024
Investors have long used shares in bitcoin miners to gain exposure to the digital currency, but there are better options available now.
Continue To Article
Personal Finance
No One Can Find Safe-Deposit Boxes Anymore
November 14, 2024
As banks close branches, many are ditching a traditional service that they consider to be outdated.
Continue To Article
Advertisement
Politics
2.3 Million Jobs: The Federal Workforce, in Charts
President-elect Donald Trump and Elon Musk want to slash the ranks of government employees; 70% of civilian workers are in military-related agencies
Continue To Article
Precious Metals
Gold Prices Set For Worst Week Since 2021 in Aftermath of Trump’s Victory
Gold prices are on track for their worst weekly decline in more than three years, pressured down by profit-taking, a stronger U.S. dollar and waning interest rate cut hopes following Donald Trump’s victory in the U.S. election.
Continue To Article
Best of the Web | opinion
Opinion: Did Trump Just Save Women’s Sports?
Democrats start to rethink their enforcement of progressive dogma.
Continue To Article
Markets
Investors Are Betting on a Market Melt-Up
They have flocked to stock funds at a pace rarely seen since 2008, but some are warning that shares look expensive historically.
Continue To Article
Ivanka Trump has been living the high life in her $24 million Miami megamansion
Since 2021, Ivanka has pursued a celebrity lifestyle, traveling the world, attending red carpet events, and renovating the mansion.
Continue To Article
The Fed’s Long-Awaited Rate Cut Will Be Felt Throughout the Property Market
Though less reliant on borrowing, the luxury sector will get a jolt of confidence from an active market, resulting in faster home sales, experts say
Continue To Article
Videos
Most Popular news
The Rural Areas Pushing for Divorce From Democratic Cities
The Rural Areas Pushing for Divorce From Democratic Cities
A $12,000 Surgery to Change Eye Color Is Surging in Popularity
A $12,000 Surgery to Change Eye Color Is Surging in Popularity
For Retirees in Their 60s, the Move That Adds Years to a Nest Egg
For Retirees in Their 60s, the Move That Adds Years to a Nest Egg
Messy Fight for Trump’s Treasury Chief Spills Into Public
Messy Fight for Trump’s Treasury Chief Spills Into Public
A Powerful AI Breakthrough Is About to Transform the World
A Powerful AI Breakthrough Is About to Transform the World
Most Popular opinion
Opinion: America’s Worst Mayor Keeps Losing
America’s Worst Mayor Keeps Losing
Opinion: The DOGE Cheat Sheet
The DOGE Cheat Sheet
Opinion: The Musk-Ramaswamy Project Could Be Trump’s Best Idea
The Musk-Ramaswamy Project Could Be Trump’s Best Idea
Opinion: Disruption Won’t Work at Treasury
Disruption Won’t Work at Treasury
Opinion: The Strange World of RFK Jr.
The Strange World of RFK Jr.
Recommended Videos
Who Is Pete Hegseth, Trump’s Controversial Pick for Secretary of Defense?
Who Is Pete Hegseth, Trump’s Controversial Pick for Secretary of Defense?
Xi Meets Biden, Says He Is ‘Ready to Work With A New U.S. Administration’
Xi Meets Biden, Says He Is ‘Ready to Work With A New U.S. Administration’
WSJ Opinion: The Trump Protests Fizzle
WSJ Opinion: The Trump Protests Fizzle
Red Lobster’s New CEO Breaks Down His $70 Million Comeback Plan
Red Lobster’s New CEO Breaks Down His $70 Million Comeback Plan
WSJ Opinion: Elon Musk Takes On